Kumogakure no Sato Equipment Mar 9, 2023 22:22:34 GMT -5
Toff E
Nindo Goes Here: Edit Profile > Personal > Most Recent Status
groupGlobal Moderator
age
birthday
rank
occupation
Okay so, coming back to these. Giving them another run through, and having gotten a second opinion from Yoritomo to inquire as to a few of the points made. The following are all of the points on these that would need change for these to be approvable.
Karasu no Tsubasa - References a different item, but doesn't link to it please fix this.
- Remove mention of the chakra use inside of the description that is bolded, "Crafted with plastic-fabric based polymer, but without the chakra reactive elements of the Wingsuit the Karasu no Tsubasa when not in active use appears most commonly as a jacket, cloak, poncho, or in the case of Kumogakure no Sato's Special Ops, as a black trench coat. However when activated by chakra the layers of the fabric extend and form a thin barrier to catch the wind akin to a kekkai(barrier) ninjutsu slowing the shinobi's descent and giving him some control over his fall."
- Furthermore with the ability to glide on a C rank item, there should be some sort of downside, like the inability to use one's arms while in flight (since logically they'd have to be directing/adjusting the wing) which in turn would limit ability to use jutsu and the like since you can't render handseals.
There'd also be the question of can people use fuuton techniques to cause lift, which effectively means that as long as someone has the proper fuuton tech, they can have flight from a C rank item. If allowed it need to be a B-Rank or higher anyways, because true flight is a pretty big thing only capable of by a few clans and SA&W stuff, which should not be reasonably recreated with a C-Rank piece of equipment.
Overall, this still desperately needs to be a B-Rank item at least to do what this is seemingly designed for.
----
Sandasutoraiku - Doesn't really seem to have anything that qualifies it as being a village equipment still, but one could argue the same for Ame's mobility gear to some regard. Likewise though, the item sets a precedent for grappling hook contraptions on the site. Lower this to no more than 5 meters of range. Besides 50 meters being aggregiously high, the ODMG only reaches 18 meters at a max, and it is MUCH larger then this in terms of what it could potentially hold for firing to yank someone.
- Fails to mention a potential downside that stems from basic physics: If you are 150lbs and you try to pull 500lbs, you're just going to get pulled towards it. Where as this reads like the wear of the weapon just decides when they get pulled or when stuff gets pulled towards them. - Remove "but may pull up to 750lbs once before burning out.", this should not have a higher max to the maximum was set.
- What exactly is allowing the head to launch/retract? There should be a mechanism, but if it's not run by chakra, and it can not be as a C-Rank item, then something else needs to be running it which should mean there's a maximum number of times it can be used. [5 Shots a thread] should more than do for 99% of cases in that regard, this thing shouldn't be getting used like spider-man web slinging after all.
This also desperately, from my perspective, wants to be chakra reactive.
----
Kodo Hai - This should not generally be breathing underwater as the intention and equipment to filter air from water, and to gather oxygen that is clean at high altitudes, like this mask, are very different mechanisms. Generally it just should be left to a rebreather (which I believe you apped before as well?), please remove mentions of working underwater.
----
Flak Jacket - I did not catch this at first, but please remove "and most important non-conductive lest Kaminari no Kuni's resident shinobi turn themselves into unintentional lightning rods." A lack of electrical conduction in the physical description of the item when that should really be an ability of it does not work as an aside. Most shinobi should not, usually be getting cross-fired by their own jutsu. Also to note... Sasuke had like 30 belts with metal on his arms while usin chidori the first time... your probably fine. XD
- The description also lists that it's light weight, strong and flexible. This is the basic effect of all Flak Jackets and counts as its basic equipment ability. In that regard, this would be a B-Rank equipment when placed next to other universal flak jackets; please choose if this is supplementary gear that protects people from dying out fast or is basic defensive gear.
- The staunching ability, again, I don't have huge issues with. Re-reading, however, it mentions toxins being slowed. The only way those are being slowed is if this armor is cutting off circulation all throughout the body, which hardly seems to be "flexible" then.
TLDR;; this absolutely should be a B-Rank unless the Staunching effect is replacing the basic armor protection of the flak jacket.
----
All in all, the items are trying to do too much for C ranks. Very few of them genuinely feel like village items outside of "the villagers tend to use this." Which is fine if it's flavor, but I will re-iterate the point of village exclusive gear is to be things that only a village can make. This does extend to standard issue gear, but I generally would like to avoid every village having 50 variants of "their flak jacket" inside of the equipment board.
|
|